Bushfire Appeals
News  |  Social Affairs

Court Rules on Belle Gibson Charity Deception

Thursday, 16th March 2017 at 11:03 am
Lina Caneva
The Federal Court has found self-proclaimed fundraiser and fake cancer survivor Belle Gibson guilty of misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to claims about her charitable donations made through the sale of a promotional book and an online application.

Thursday, 16th March 2017
at 11:03 am
Lina Caneva



Court Rules on Belle Gibson Charity Deception
Thursday, 16th March 2017 at 11:03 am

The Federal Court has found self-proclaimed fundraiser and fake cancer survivor Belle Gibson guilty of misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to claims about her charitable donations made through the sale of a promotional book and an online application.

In her judgement in the Federal Court on Wednesday, Justice Debra Mortimer said: “All Ms Gibson’s marketing of herself and her company projected the image of a successful, booming enterprise with a wholesale dedication to charitable giving.

“Any reasonable member of the community reading the statements from The Whole Pantry Facebook or Instagram accounts would be led, erroneously, to believe that this was an enterprise where substantial proportions of what people paid over to purchase the apps or the book would be given to charitable causes, on a regular and ongoing basis.”

In the court proceedings initiated by Consumer Affairs Victoria it was alleged Gibson (Annabelle Natalie Gibson), claimed to have been diagnosed with brain cancer and rejected conventional cancer treatments in favour of embarking on a quest to heal herself naturally and had developed and promoted a smartphone application and a book.

The court heard that Gibson promoted herself both under her own name and under a business name, The Whole Pantry. It heard that while she claimed part of the proceeds from sales of the application and the book would be donated to charities, many or most of these donations were not made. The charities involved were One Girl, the Asylum Seekers Resource Centre, the Birthing Kit Foundation and the Schwarz family, which was raising funds for treatment for their son.

“I am satisfied [Gibson] engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive in contravention of  s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) and the ACL (Vic),” Justice Mortimer said.

The judge reserved her decision on whether any penalties should apply to a date to be fixed.

Reports casting doubt on Gibson’s cancer diagnosis and allegations of missing donations surfaced in March 2015. Gibson did not appear during the Federal Court hearing.

Legal resource not-for-profit organisation Justice Connect said the findings in the Gibson trial demonstrated that the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) was an effective weapon in prosecuting misleading and deceptive conduct by fraudulent charity fundraisers.

“Fittingly, the judgment was handed down by Justice Mortimer of the Federal Court on World Consumer Rights Day,” director not-for-profit law at Justice Connect Sue Woodward said.

“The Federal Court’s finding shows that the nationwide ACL is well up to the task when it comes to prosecuting fundraising misbehaviour in the not-for-profit sector, and that the Victorian Commissioner for Consumer Affairs was right to use it in Belle Gibson’s case rather than the state-based Fundraising Act.

“While the penalty is yet to be determined, the national consumer law arms the regulator and courts with other enforcement tools where fines are impractical. This is important when a fundraiser or fraudulent charity has no money, as is the case with Belle Gibson.”

Woodward, who is part of the NFP sector’s campaign called #fixfundraising, said: “Our campaign argues that with the seven different state and territory laws, any charities that aspire to collect Australia-wide, or even small groups using the internet to raise funds, must abide by a minefield of rules and regulations that add millions of dollars in unnecessary cost to the not-for-profit sector.

“The duplicative and complex nature of Australia’s current regime, with charities having to deal with both the Australian consumer law and the archaic state-based laws, diverts and distracts many wonderful volunteers from compassionate activities to mind-numbing and unnecessary paperwork.”

The Victorian government has also publicly confirmed the need for nationally consistent fundraising regulation.

In her opening address to the National Consumer Congress in Melbourne, Minister for Consumer Affairs Marlene Kariouz said she supported the community sector’s call to “overhaul this aspect of the Australian consumer law”.

She said she hoped that her colleagues in other jurisdictions shared the same view, and most importantly that she would “continue to advocate for national reform while taking appropriate action to remove red tape for charities and not-for-profits operating in Victoria”.

“Legislation currently in the Parliament will enable me to exempt an incorporated association or a class of associations from annual financial reporting requirements where they are also registered with and reporting to another regulator,” Kariouz said.

Woodward said: “Minister Kariouz is the first state government minister to say publicly during the Australian consumer law review process that fundraising laws across Australia need to change, and the Australian consumer law is the way forward. Other consumer affairs ministers should follow her lead.”

Lina Caneva  |  Editor  |  @ProBonoNews

Lina Caneva has been a journalist for more than 35 years. She was the editor of Pro Bono Australia News from when it was founded in 2000 until 2018.

Got a story to share?

Got a news tip or article idea for Pro Bono News? Or perhaps you would like to write an article and join a growing community of sector leaders sharing their thoughts and analysis with Pro Bono News readers?

Get in touch at news@probonoaustralia.com.au

Get more stories like this


Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


A fair and just go for all

Maggie Coggan

Monday, 18th November 2019 at 8:25 am

Legal NFP powerhouses unite for global impact

Maggie Coggan

Thursday, 14th November 2019 at 8:38 am

Charity leaders slam continued inaction on fundraising reform

Luke Michael

Friday, 30th August 2019 at 5:14 pm

Government under pressure to take action on fundraising reform

Luke Michael

Thursday, 15th August 2019 at 8:19 am


NDIS not yet in tune with the needs of participants

Luke Michael

Monday, 20th January 2020 at 4:46 pm

What impact will the bushfire crisis have on homelessness?

Luke Michael

Wednesday, 15th January 2020 at 4:28 pm

New fund paves the way for impact investment in the charity sector

Luke Michael

Friday, 17th January 2020 at 4:34 pm

The rise (and scepticism) of Facebook fundraisers

Maggie Coggan

Thursday, 16th January 2020 at 8:49 am

Bushfire Appeals
pba inverse logo
Subscribe Twitter Facebook

Get the social sector's most essential news coverage. Delivered free to your inbox every Tuesday and Thursday morning.

You have Successfully Subscribed!