Close Search
News  |  General

Future-proof Australia Against Welfare Dependency and Inequality

18 November 2014 at 10:46 am
Xavier Smerdon
Australians should all care about the findings of the Productivity Commission Inquiry into Childcare and Early Childhood Learning, recently delivered to the Federal Government and due to be tabled soon, because it affects our future prosperity as a nation, says Executive Director of The Benevolent Society, Matt Gardiner.

Xavier Smerdon | 18 November 2014 at 10:46 am


Future-proof Australia Against Welfare Dependency and Inequality
18 November 2014 at 10:46 am

Australians should all care about the findings of the Productivity Commission Inquiry into Childcare and Early Childhood Learning, recently delivered to the Federal Government and due to be tabled soon, because it affects our future prosperity as a nation, says Executive Director of The Benevolent Society, Matt Gardiner.

This is a once in a generation opportunity to future-proof Australia against entrenched welfare dependency, inequality and lack of opportunity amongst a significant proportion of today’s children— tomorrow’s adults.

How the Federal Government responds to this report—which recommendations it accepts and acts on, and which it rejects —matters to the wellbeing of millions of children who are yet to enter the early learning system, and ultimately it should matter to us all.

In its submission to the Productivity Commission inquiry, Price Waterhouse Cooper has done the nation a great service by producing a detailed, high quality report:  Putting a value on early childhood education and care in Australia (1)

It found that putting more vulnerable children into quality early learning childhood education and care will add $20bn to our GDP over the next 35 years—and that’s not even counting the dollars saved by these kids not ending up on welfare and other associated social costs of entrenched disadvantage and social misery.

Importantly, this is about not only giving kids the best opportunity to access preschool, but access to quality preschool.

We need a shift in the collective mind-set in Australia—from seeing childcare or preschool as babysitting, to realising that quality education in the early years sets children up for success in life.

The issue here for the nation’s productivity is not just about the dollar value of women’s participation in the workforce, it’s about what this means for the children themselves.  We already know this. Extensive international and Australian research (2) has established that investment in quality early childhood education is a critical factor for determining long-term success for disadvantaged children.

The reason we need to address this now is that we are currently failing at least a fifth of our children who are not developmentally ready when they start school.

Australia is unique in the world in being able to measure school readiness nationally, through the  Australian Early Development Census [AEDC]. The last time the census was taken in 2012, of 289,000 children starting school across Australia, 1-in-5, or 22 per cent, were vulnerable in at least one area of development. For Aboriginal and Torres Straight Islander children the rate of developmental vulnerability is double this at around 43 per cent.(3)

The AEDC will collect this data again on all children starting school next year—and this will be the best measurement we will have of whether we are investing enough in early childhood education and care to reduce this worrying number.

If our quality of early learning and care has not improved since 2012, at least another 50,000 children will enter the school system each year more likely to fail—at school … and potentially at life.

We know that quality early preschool results in improved educational outcomes.  A 2013 Melbourne University study which analysed data from the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children found that children who went to preschool with university trained educators had significantly higher levels of academic achievement as measured by NAPLAN scores in year 3.(4)

Oxford University researchers involved in the Effective Pre-School, Primary and Secondary (EPPSE) study—the first longitudinal study of its kind in the world—found that children who had had early education experience at nursery or preschool were more likely to get better high school test results. (5)

Tony Abbott says the number one priority for this government is to get Aboriginal kids into school; and Assistant Education Minister, Sussan Ley, says this government is committed to do whatever it can to ensure that children get the best possible start in life, and that every child transitions well to school – especially disadvantaged and vulnerable children. (6)

If they mean what they say, the Government must accept any Productivity Commission recommendation which ensure an ongoing commitment to investing in quality early education and care—especially for Australia’s most vulnerable children.

There are two Productivity Commission recommendations the Government should reject (if they are in the final report):

1)      Reducing the qualification levels required for educators working with 0-3 year olds.

This would be a massive backward step. When children’s brains are in their most formative phase, they need the secure care of well trained professionals.

2)       Introducing requirements for unemployed parents to study or work a set number of hours before they qualify for a childcare subsidy.

This could see thousands of our most vulnerable children denied access to quality early learning—a price we will all pay in the long run, as these are the very children that high quality early childhood education and care benefits the most, so it’s our best hope of breaking the inter-generational cycle of disadvantage. (7)

Based on all the evidence, ensuring that more Australian children have the benefit of quality early education and care is an investment the government can easily justify and reconcile. It will pay off in more children succeeding at school and in life, reduced future welfare spending and billions of dollars added to our gross domestic product.

About the author: Matt Gardiner is an Executive Director of The Benevolent Society. Gardiner has worked in various clinical and executive roles. He has a Master’s Degree in Counselling and  majored in Psychology as an undergraduate.

(1)           Putting a value on early childhood education and care in Australia, Price Waterhouse Cooper, September 2014

(2)           Acting Early Changing Lives, The Benevolent Society, October 2013

(3)           Australian Early Development Census

(4)           Early Bird Catches the Worm: The Causal Impact of Pre-school Participation and Teacher Qualifications on Year 3 National NAPLAN Cognitive Tests  Warren, D & Haisken De-New, J, MIAESR U of Melb , October 2013

(5)           Effective Preschool, Primary & Secondary Education research project, University of London & Oxford University, September 2014

(6)           The Australian: Bidto lift indigenous school attendance rates has stalled: Abbott, Patricia Karvelhas 23/10/14

ABC News: More children set to fail at school unless they are better prepared at a younger age, Rebecca Barratt, 23/10/14

(7)           Productivity Commission Inquiry into Childcare and Early Childhood Learning draft report, July 2014

Xavier Smerdon  |  Journalist  |  @XavierSmerdon

Xavier Smerdon is a journalist specialising in the Not for Profit sector. He writes breaking and investigative news articles.

PB Careers
Get your biweekly dose of news, opinion and analysis to keep you up to date with what’s happening and why it matters for you, sent every Tuesday and Thursday morning.

Got a story to share?

Got a news tip or article idea for Pro Bono News? Or perhaps you would like to write an article and join a growing community of sector leaders sharing their thoughts and analysis with Pro Bono News readers? Get in touch at or download our contributor guidelines.




Get more stories like this


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Meet Pro Bono News’ first editorial advisory board

Wendy Williams

Thursday, 16th April 2020 at 8:02 am

Filling the Service Gaps That People Keep Falling Through

Dr Tessa Boyd-Caine

Tuesday, 5th September 2017 at 8:41 am

Survey Reveals Australian Attitudes to Torture in Conflict

Lina Caneva

Tuesday, 6th December 2016 at 3:05 pm

Indigenous Advocate Named 2016 Telstra Business Woman of the Year

Lina Caneva

Tuesday, 22nd November 2016 at 12:30 pm

pba inverse logo
Subscribe Twitter Facebook

We need your help.

Since the outbreak of COVID-19, Pro Bono Australia has seen a devastating fall in advertising and less people posting on our job board, which is how we fund our free news service. You can show us that you value the work we do by making a contribution.

 Make a contribution 

You have Successfully Subscribed!