Close Search
News  |  Policy

Australia Warned Not to Follow NZ Welfare Reform

23 October 2017 at 12:29 pm
Wendy Williams
Australia must be careful not to follow in New Zealand’s footsteps when it comes to welfare reform, an international advocate has warned.

Wendy Williams | 23 October 2017 at 12:29 pm


Australia Warned Not to Follow NZ Welfare Reform
23 October 2017 at 12:29 pm

Australia must be careful not to follow in New Zealand’s footsteps when it comes to welfare reform, an international advocate has warned.

Vanessa Cole, the coordinator for Auckland Action Against Poverty (AAAP), a direct action, advocacy and education group, has cautioned Australia on the dangers of repeating the New Zealand experience of increasing punishment and hardship.

Speaking at the two-day annual Anti-Poverty Week conference Attack Poverty, Not The Poor, hosted by Anti-Poverty Network SA, Cole told Pro Bono News AAAP was formed in 2010 in response to a wave of welfare reforms introduced by the New Zealand National government.

She said the organisation had been using a variety of ways to fight against reforms that had “shifted the welfare system” and placed an emphasis on getting beneficiaries into work.

“The last 40 years of neoliberal reforms has led to such a massive attack on beneficiaries in all forms, that fighting back against it is difficult,” Cole said.

“There are always different ways that you need to tackle such a big problem.

“[It is] having different tactics and different strategies and using those across the board to try to fight back from different angles.

“We have… systems of punishment in our welfare system where people are treated really terribly when they go to get assistance and they are humiliated and so we [do] individual advocacy with people but also trying to organise and campaign and try to change narratives and challenge the government.”

Her comments were made in the wake of the announcement on Thursday that Labour leader Jacinda Ardern has become New Zealand’s newest prime minister.

But Cole said while it was a change after nine years of National government, they did not “have a lot of faith in the Labour government”.

“The Labour government is the party that brought in neoliberal reforms in the 90s,” she said.

“They don’t have a track record of supporting beneficiaries.

“The Greens party in New Zealand this year, leading up to the election brought out a quite progressive welfare policy which involved an increase in all benefits by 20 per cent, ending all sanctions or obligations for beneficiaries… and so they want to remove all of that punitive structure within the welfare system and actually mend the safety net.

“So the Green Party is in coalition with Labour, but Labour has made absolutely no commitment to taking on the Green’s welfare policy, so if we see after Labour settles in that they don’t agree to take on the Green Party’s welfare policy then they are just as much of a target for us as the National Party were.”

She said the push by governments to get rid of the safety net was the result of a desire to reduce welfare spending.

“Both Labour and National have committed to trying to get a surplus in a time when we should be spending more than ever on welfare and housing,” Cole said.

“That fits in nicely with the neoliberal agenda of trying to reduce public spending.

“While they are reducing spending to essential social services, they are subsidising corporate interests and so, there is a dismantling of the welfare state and it came through pushing an ideology around unemployment being the fault of unemployed people.”

Cole said AAAP was “really firm” that unemployment was not caused by the unemployed.

“It is caused systemically and is a result of the changing way in which work exists,” she said.

“Unemployment is used globally to drive down wages and so there is a focus on work being the solution to get out of poverty but there’s not actually jobs for people to go into and definitely not jobs that provide people with security.

“But they are pushing that ideology so that they can dismantle the welfare state and cut public spending.”

She said the levels of benefits were currently so low that people could not “live in dignity”.

“People can’t afford basic necessities let alone be able to participate in society,” she said.

“It is keeping benefit rates so low that if you are on a benefit you are going to be living below the poverty line and it is a form of punishment.

“Also those in work are likely to be living below the poverty line because the nature of the work is so precarious and people don’t have enough hours, people don’t have enough pay and so materially this form of punishment of the poor keeps people below the poverty line and really this work focus is forcing people into really bad jobs that companies can end up profiting from. A situation of people living in poverty.”

Cole said the solution was not simple.

“I think the most important thing is to ensure we are organising to get together to make change, that we are not letting policies go through without being challenged by people, that we don’t let the government get away with treating people with no dignity and making policies that are harmful to people in communities,” she said.

“The most important thing is that we stay strong and we collectivise and we organise and keep people educated. That’s the way that we are going to continue to resist changes to welfare.”

St. Vincent De Paul CEO Dr John Falzon, who delivered the keynote at the conference on Friday, said it was time to embrace a new framework.

“It’s time we embraced a policy framework developed by the people who know the most about poverty: the people experiencing it,” Falzon said.

“It’s time we embraced a framework that provides security rather than heightened insecurity; income adequacy rather than income management; respect rather than paternalism; dignity rather than demonisation.”

The Attack Poverty, Not The Poor conference, organised by low-income people themselves, explored issues surrounding electricity prices, government-funded job agencies, mental health and poverty, and the “closing of the Disability Pension door”.

Welfare recipients, including job-seekers, disability pensioners, sole parents, students and carers, also shared their experiences, in a bid to “challenge the federal government’s tired old game of blaming and judging the poor for their plight”.

Anti-Poverty Network SA state coordinator Pas Forgione said they had a “clear message for Canberra”.

“Stop punishing those who through no fault of their own, are out of work, and start listening to the people in the firing line,” Forgione said.

“Our meagre welfare payments contribute to one in seven adults and one in six children living in poverty. Newstart is $269 per week – $160 per week below the poverty-line. Yet the government tells us as our welfare system is somehow too generous and too lenient.

“Instead of more attacks – whether cashless welfare, forced drug-testing, or the stressful, time-wasting obligations imposed by government-funded job agencies – let’s attack the real problems. It’s the grim ratio of job vacancies vs. job-seekers – one job for every 11 job-seekers – that should be our focus, not the characters of the unemployed.”

Wendy Williams  |  Editor  |  @WendyAnWilliams

Wendy Williams is a journalist specialising in the not-for-profit sector and broader social economy. She has been the editor of Pro Bono News since 2018.

PB Careers
Get your biweekly dose of news, opinion and analysis to keep you up to date with what’s happening and why it matters for you, sent every Tuesday and Thursday morning.

Got a story to share?

Got a news tip or article idea for Pro Bono News? Or perhaps you would like to write an article and join a growing community of sector leaders sharing their thoughts and analysis with Pro Bono News readers? Get in touch at or download our contributor guidelines.


Panel Discussion Webinar

Your email address will not be published.


Focus on politics: Victoria

Neil Pharaoh

Monday, 20th June 2022 at 4:06 pm

The value of working in the charities sector

David Crosbie

Thursday, 16th June 2022 at 8:54 am

Leigh hits the ground running as charities minister

Danielle Kutchel

Wednesday, 15th June 2022 at 4:21 pm

pba inverse logo
Subscribe Twitter Facebook

News for those with purpose.

Delivered free to your inbox every Tuesday and Thursday morning. 

Thank you - you have successfully subscribed.

Get the social sector's most essential news coverage. Delivered free to your inbox every Tuesday and Thursday morning.

You have Successfully Subscribed!